Wednesday, December 24, 2025

AI Power Demand, Grid Limits, and the Displacement of Climate Politics

This essay brackets climate science entirely and examines AI power demand as an electrical engineering and infrastructure problem.

For years, I dismissed anthropogenic global warming (AGW) as a political and rhetorical construct whose practical consequences would eventually be overtaken by some other, more immediate disruption. History suggested this was likely: large, abstract, long-horizon problems rarely get resolved on their own terms. They are usually superseded by nearer, harder constraints that reorder priorities overnight.

I assumed that disruption might be geological or astronomical — volcanic activity, an asteroid, or some other exogenous shock. What never occurred to me was that the disruptor would be self-inflicted: artificial intelligence and its unprecedented appetite for electrical power.

What follows is an engineering argument for why AI power demand is likely to overwhelm electrical grids regardless of one’s position on AGW, why efficiency gains will not solve the problem, and why current energy and climate policy is internally inconsistent in ways that cannot be sustained.

For a long time, I assumed that the climate debate would eventually be displaced by some other hard constraint. I was right about the displacement — and wrong about what would cause it.

1. Bracketing the AGW Debate

Before going any further, it is worth being explicit about what this piece is not.

It is not necessary to accept the AGW narrative in order to see the problem clearly.

Human perception of climate is local, episodic, and noisy. A modest shift in global average temperature does not guarantee noticeable change in any particular place, and many people — myself included — have not experienced a dramatic, lived change in seasonal patterns over a lifetime. Skepticism based on lived experience is not ignorance; it reflects the mismatch between statistical abstractions and phenomenological reality.

But even if AGW were entirely correct, entirely incorrect, or somewhere in between, the conclusions of this paper would not change. The contradiction I am concerned with exists independently of climate models.

2. The Core Contradiction

If carbon emissions represent an existential threat that justifies outlawing coal and natural gas, then the simultaneous build-out of the largest continuous electrical loads in human history is irrational.

AI data centers are not incremental loads. They are step functions.

A single hyperscale AI facility now demands tens to hundreds of megawatts of continuous power — equivalent to a steel mill, operating 24/7, with little tolerance for interruption. These facilities are being permitted, subsidized, and connected to grids that are already aging, capacity-constrained, and fragile.

You cannot simultaneously declare energy austerity and pursue unconstrained AI expansion. Yet that is exactly what current policy attempts to do.

3. Why Renewables Cannot Carry This Load

This is not an ideological claim. It is arithmetic and physics.

Solar and wind suffer from low capacity factors, intermittency, land-use intensity, and material demands that scale poorly. Grid-scale storage sufficient to cover multi-day or multi-week gaps does not exist at anything close to the required scale, nor is it being deployed fast enough to matter.

Renewables can contribute meaningfully at the margins. They cannot supply dense, continuous, rapidly growing baseload demand of the sort AI requires.

4. Nuclear: The Obvious Answer That Politics Blocks

Nuclear power is the only scalable, low-carbon baseload energy source that could plausibly support large-scale AI growth.

Modern Gen III+ reactors are already extremely safe by any rational engineering standard. Small modular reactors and Gen IV designs offer further promise, though timelines remain long.

The barriers are not technical. They are political, regulatory, and cultural — frozen in the fears of the late 20th century.

Absent a political reset, nuclear remains talked about and deferred rather than built.

5. Efficiency Will Not Save the Grid

The idea that compute efficiency gains (hardware or software) will reduce total energy consumption is historically naïve.

Efficiency improvements almost always trigger increased usage — a phenomenon known as Jevons’ Paradox. Compute is particularly elastic:

  • Cheaper FLOPs lead to larger models
  • Faster inference leads to more queries
  • Better capability leads to more applications
  • Strategic value drives further expansion

There is no natural mechanism that converts efficiency into restraint. Without explicit caps or rationing (bigger government, more regulation — my nemesis), efficiency gains will be reinvested into bigger, faster, smarter AI — not lower power consumption.

6. Grid Reality: The True Bottleneck

Regardless of climate beliefs, electrical grids face hard constraints:

  • Aging transmission infrastructure
  • Transformer manufacturing bottlenecks
  • Long interconnection queues
  • Thermal derating during heat waves
  • Poor margins for reactive power and stability

AI data centers stress all of these simultaneously. They represent the worst possible load profile: continuous, dense, fast-growing, and interruption-intolerant.

Grid failure does not arrive as a single collapse. It arrives as price spikes, brownouts, priority loads, and quiet rationing.

7. Why Governments Accept the Risk

Governments are not confused. They are prioritizing.

AI is viewed — correctly or not — as a general-purpose strategic multiplier with military, intelligence, and economic implications. Losing leadership in AI is considered more dangerous than grid strain, higher prices, or localized outages.

As a result:

  • Data centers receive priority access to power
  • Emissions rules are bent or waived quietly
  • Reliability is sacrificed before strategic capability

Climate policy remains rhetorically useful, but operationally flexible.

8. Displacement, Not Resolution

AI power demand does not refute AGW. It displaces it.

When policymakers face immediate, local, and undeniable constraints — blackouts, grid instability, national security pressure — abstract long-horizon optimization problems slide down the priority list.

This is how history works.

AGW did not need to be disproven to lose primacy. It only needed competition from a more immediate form of power hunger.

Conclusion

The electrical grid — not climate models — will be the ultimate constraint on AI growth.

Efficiency gains will press harder against that constraint, not relieve it. Renewables cannot carry the load alone. Nuclear remains politically blocked. Coal and gas bans collide with strategic reality.

The result is policy incoherence that will persist until forced to change by price shocks, reliability failures, or geopolitical necessity.

This outcome was predictable. The only real surprise is the identity of the disruptor.

AI, not climate, is now the problem that cannot be deferred.

Sunday, May 25, 2025

The Wrecking Ball Swings Both Ways

Why Limited Government is the Only Real Protection in a Divided Nation

In a time when politics feels more divisive than ever, it’s worth asking: Why do we care so much who’s in power? Why do elections feel like existential threats? Why are friendships, families, and communities torn apart over national politics?

It’s not because we’ve all gone mad. It’s because government has grown too large, too intrusive, and too eager to solve problems it was never meant to touch.

"If government were less intrusive, then politics would be less divisive.
If government would stay the hell out of our problems, most people wouldn't care which party was in power." -- Karl Uppiano

That’s not cynicism—it’s clarity. When government controls your health care, your kids’ education, your business regulations, your energy bill, and your speech on social media, of course people panic when “the other side” wins. Because control of government now means control over everything.

This is why people who claim to love liberty should be skeptical of any political movement that promises to "fix" everything from the top down. Even if you agree with their goals, centralized power is a loaded weapon—and one day, it will be in someone else’s hands.

"If you hate Donald Trump, and everything he says or does, then you should be very interested in limited government.
That wrecking ball swings both ways." -- Karl Uppiano

The same is true if you hated Barack Obama. Or Joe Biden. Or George W. Bush. If your solution to every problem is to expand federal authority, you're building the stage for tyranny—whether it's a tyranny you like or not.

“Of all tyrannies, a tyranny sincerely exercised for the good of its victims may be the most oppressive. It would be better to live under robber barons than under omnipotent moral busybodies. The robber baron's cruelty may sometimes sleep, his cupidity may at some point be satiated; but those who torment us for our own good will torment us without end for they do so with the approval of their own conscience. They may be more likely to go to Heaven yet at the same time likelier to make a Hell of earth. This very kindness stings with intolerable insult. To be "cured" against one's will and cured of states which we may not regard as disease is to be put on a level of those who have not yet reached the age of reason or those who never will; to be classed with infants, imbeciles, and domestic animals.” -- C. S. Lewis

Founding principles like limited government, federalism, separation of powers, and checks and balances weren’t designed just to frustrate political progress—they were designed to protect you from power when it turns against you.

It’s tempting to cheer when your side wins and gets to “do something,” but history shows us that every tool you create to force your vision on others will one day be used against you. That’s not a glitch in the system—it’s the nature of power.

In short: if you’re worried about the next election, the next president, or the next wave of regulations, don’t just focus on who holds power. Start asking how much power they should have in the first place.

Because if we don’t restore the principle of limited government, we’re not just fighting each other—we’re setting fire to the very system that was designed to keep us free.

Sunday, April 13, 2025

180 Gram Vinyl Records

 The vinyl record resurgence has been fun, but I've been mystified by one development, and that's the obsession with 180-gram new pressings. Seriously, why do we need to use that much vinyl? Isn't vinyl made from petrochemicals, which are supposedly environmentally unfriendly, and increasingly scarce?

We're told that heavy vinyl sounds better. Theoretically that extra mass provides more resistance to the stylus following those wildly modulating grooves, and the extra angular momentum smooths out wow & flutter and damps out noise.

Um, no. First, the stylus is a very low mass object, and it doesn’t require that much force to accelerate it, even at the highest audio frequencies. The intrinsic shape and stiffness of the vinyl ought to be more than enough to guide the stylus through it’s gyrating journey.

As far as wow & flutter are concerned, unless the record player has a very flimsy turntable, a heavier record isn’t going to make a significant contribution to the overall angular momentum. Frankly, if someone is listening with such flimsy equipment, they’re probably not concerned that much with sound quality anyway. If you need more support and inertia, a more effective solution would be to buy a high-density turntable mat once and for all.

In fact, a record doesn’t need to be much thicker than about twice the maximum groove depth, to play back correctly. Maybe some additional stiffness would help with handling, but that’s about it.

I’ve also heard superstitious claims about warpage, but I have heard conflicting claims about whether thicker or thinner vinyl are more prone to it. I have hundreds of records, and warpage simply hasn’t been an issue. Excessive heat is the worst culprit. Store in a cool dry place, and you’ll be fine.

I have some RCA Dynaflex records from back in the ‘70s that sounded fantastic and still do. Dynaflex records were lighter and more flexible than most. RCA was criticized at the time for cheaping out on the vinyl, but I thought it was brilliant. That was in the middle of the oil crisis, and it seemed like a good way to economize on raw materials, without having to raise the price of the music. Other record labels used recycled vinyl, which sounded like Rice Krispies in milk. Snap, Crackle, Pop.

I think we should re-introduce Dynaflex.

Friday, January 20, 2023

WxService Update Available

    WxMonitor ow4j230125

    • Switched to darker gray background for wind image display. Darker gray provides better contrast and readability.
    • Display wind direction when wind speed is zero. Users would like to know which way the wind vane is pointing even if the wind isn't blowing.

    Monday, February 21, 2022

    WxService Update Available

    WxService ow4j220221

    • Updated to OWAPI 1.2 (One-Wire API 64 bits)

    WxMonitor ow4j220221

    • Switched to default Java platform look & feel (from system L&F)
    System look & feel was too unpredictable between Windows, KDE and Gnome desktops. Using default Java makes it look the same everywhere (it looks like Java everywhere).

    Monday, January 17, 2022

    COVID Vaccine Risk Assessment

    Dr. Campbell goes over the official COVID vaccine health risks, and then describes one specific way to avoid risk: Aspiration (pulling back the syringe to check for blood before injecting). Aspiration will indicate whether the needle has entered a vein or artery, which dramatically increases the risk of adverse effects. Note that Denmark is the only country with aspiration as part of the protocol. Not the UK, and not the US. 



    Sunday, January 16, 2022

    End of the Line for COVID?

    UK Physician Dr. John Campbell has been analyzing the actual data on his YouTube channel. He seems to be more objective and informative than the mainstream media. 


    How long will it take public policy to respond to the actual data? The writing has been on the wall for quite a while, but mandates remain in effect.

    Wednesday, September 22, 2021

    WxService Update Available

    WxMonitor ow4j210922

    • Modified Wind Image rendering for faster updates
    When WxMonitor is downloading the backlog of data from the previous 12 hours on startup, it animates the display so you can see what transpired while you were away. However, the Wind Image display takes quite a lot of resources to animate at the full incoming data rate, so I made it update at 10 frames per second. It still looks smooth and you can see everything. The full dataset still gets pushed through all the filters, so the highs and lows are accurately recorded. The goal is to get to real-time data display quicker.

    Saturday, August 21, 2021

    Physics Isn't Pretty

    Beauty should not be an objective for a scientific theory. I think the idea of beauty comes about when we look at a successful theory, and its elegance and its consistency with nature strike us as beautiful. Sabine gives us a summary of the state of physics as it exists today. 

    Friday, July 30, 2021

    Boston -- More Than a Feeling

    We were in the depths of disco hell in 1976. I was a sophomore or junior in college, and most pop radio was just a pain to endure. Even Paul McCartney & Wings were jumping on the disco pukewagon. 

    But there were a few bright spots: Heart, Queen and Boston. In the midst of all the same-tempo repetitive disco drivel, along comes this amazingly well recorded, sophisticated music -- harmonically, sonically, and the vocals were just superhuman. 

    I was (and still am) an audiophile, and even on heavily compressed & peak limited FM, this song sounded great. Maybe Tom Scholtz mixed it for the FM medium. I don't know. But it was one of the few times commercial FM radio actually sounded like high fidelity.

    Producer Rick Beato lays it out for you. By the way, Rick's 12-string acoustic sounds gorgeous in this video.


    I'd like to have lunch with Rick Beato sometime. What a musical mind.

    How to Use Auxiliary Storage on Windows

     A lot of newer development and desktop Windows machines are equipped with a barely adequate solid state drive (SSD) as the system drive, and an auxiliary hard disk drive (HDD). Out of the box, Windows is barely aware of the auxiliary storage. There's a drive letter, but that's about it. If you want to actually use the HDD, you have to manage it yourself.

    You can tell Windows to change where new content is saved, and it lets you select your 'other' drive(s), but that can cause other problems. First off, it doesn't seem to follow the /Users/username/Documents pattern, but rather just goes /username/Documents. So finding things is confusing. It doesn't change your home directory, so if you open a command window, it will be in e.g., C:/Users/username. 

    Start Menu > System > Settings > Storage

    This feature actually seems to make matters worse. I would much rather that Windows copy all user data to a new location (wherever that is), and create a symbolic link in the original location that points to the new location. That would prevent existing apps having to be updated with the new location. Windows could keep the same C:/Users/username, but it would go to the new location.

    A lot of apps will keep saving their user data in C:/Users/username. Some of them put lots of data in there. For example, Netbeans, Audacity, Maven, Office 365...

    The Windows file system has symbolic links. A few different kinds, but for this discussion, you want a 'junction'. You might be tempted to copy your entire C:/Users/username folder to another drive, and create a junction to it. I think it would probably work, for the most part, but I have heard of problems with this approach. A better solution would be to create links to specific folders that are notorious for hogging a lot of space. 

    For example, the Maven repository, .m2, can become incredibly large, since it contains the downloaded libraries of all the dependencies for software projects. I moved it to D:/Users/username/.m2 (D drive is my HDD, and I just mirrored the '/Users/username/' part, for consistency). I could have told Maven where I want the .m2 repo to go, but I have several tools that use Maven, and between installs and reconfigurations, I invariably find .m2 on my C drive. It's easier just to make a junction and forget about it. Then everyone gets the same standard configuration.

    OneDrive has to get into the act, and it can really discombobulate things. OneDrive sees your standard 'libraries' (Documents, Downloads, Desktop, Pictures, Music, Videos, etc., and literally moves those from their usual location, to inside the OneDrive folder. I'm not kidding: if you go to C:/Users/username/Documents, and OneDrive got ahold of it, your Documents folder will be empty. 

    This can cause confusion, and still hog the C: drive. But don't use a junction for OneDrive. The recommended procedure is to go into your OneDrive account settings, and tell OneDrive to unlink the computer. Once OneDrive logs you out, copy the OneDrive folder to the desired new location. Then 'set up' your new-old account, and tell OneDrive where you want it to keep your stuff. When OneDrive warns you that your specified location already contains data, just say not to duplicate it.

    I think an even better approach, if OneDrive has finished syncing, is to sign out of OneDrive and just delete the old OneDrive folder. Then log back in to OneDrive and tell it to use the new (empty) location. OneDrive will simply download all your content from the cloud. 

    Saturday, July 24, 2021

    Falsifiability is King

    Note: philosophy and science used to be considered about the same thing in Newton's time. 

    Saturday, July 17, 2021

    The Big Giant Piano

    Ever since I was a baby, my grandparents had a baby grand piano sitting in the corner of their living room. While I was growing up, I used to noodle around on it from time to time. One thing I noticed was that the middle of the keyboard sounded very musical, but the bottom octave basically just growled. It was hard to tell which note was being played. Each note sounded different, but the actual pitch was indistinct. 

    It wasn't a bad piano. It's just that the bass strings were too short to sound the fundamental very well. And uprights and spinets, well, forget about it. The problem is made worse by the fact that the hammers hit the strings close to the bridge, which tends to excite more harmonics than fundamentals. 

    Even concert grands lack really clear fundamental bass notes. It's basic physics, captain. 

    When I was in high school, I learned to play 'Joy to the World' by Three Dog Night on our family's little Wurlitzer Spinet. I didn't think anything of it, until one Christmas, I was at my Great Uncle's house, and he had a concert grand in his living room. (He was a session musician in Hollywood, so of course he did!) I sat down at that piano, and started pounding out JTW by TDN. I was blown away by how good it sounded on that piano. For $40,000.00 in 1960s dollars, it better sound good!

    Well, here's a piano that would put that tinkle box to shame! Fundamental bass, baby! It's all about that bass.


    Oh and JTW by TDN, yeah. This is how boy bands sounded when I was a teenager...


    Sunday, July 11, 2021

    Tuesday, June 29, 2021

    I'm Just Putting This Here for Reference

    Whenever I need a short refresher on the fundamental particles of the standard model, I always have to track down this video. Now I'll have it until it scrolls off my backlog.



    One of the Best Explanations and Demonstrations of the Double Slit Experiment

    His description of superposition and the 'wave function collapse' finally explained in a way that doesn't defy reason. The wave function is a prediction, and a prediction is pointless after the fact. It doesn't mean physics or reality has changed.


     

    Saturday, June 26, 2021

    This Will Blow Your Mind. And Then AI Will Read It


    Remember George Harrison's song from Yellow Submarine, "It's All Too Much"? Well, this is all too much. I didn't think I would like this, and I still don't, totally. But the technology really is interesting.

    Brain and brain! What is brain?

    A Day Late, and a Dollar Short

    How many of you have grabbed a handful of CD jewel cases to go in the car, and when you open them up, one or more of them are empty? So annoying. My invention would be to have some kind of window in the cover art, so you can tell at a glance if your CD case has a CD in it. 

    This didn't seem to be as much of a problem with record albums, perhaps because vinyl records were less portable in the first place, and a record sitting on your turntable was pretty obvious. But a CD pretty much disappears into your CD player drawer. 

    It's too late now, since CDs have become more or less obsolete anyway, and millions of CD cases already don't have my brilliant invention. Too bad. So sad.